Since 1946, no serious student of mormonism has given the spaulding manuscript theory much credibility. I think even most antimormons gave up on that years ago but you never know. Ever since the book of mormon was first published in 1830, its origins have been disputed. The view of the hebrews theory of book of mormon authorship. Characters, plot, structure, style, names and religious content all paralleled the book of mormon. His book entitled the backslider is perhaps the most significant piece of mormon fiction ever written. What are the pros and cons of the spauldingrigdon theory. Or was the book really derived from solomon spalding. It is claimed by some that joseph smith either plagiarized or relied upon a manuscript by solomon spaulding to write the book of mormon. I have read every word of both it and the book of mormon, and i compiled a list of what i thought were the most noteworthy similarities between the two books.
Howes antimormon book mormonism unvailed, family members and other. It may be possible for literary analysts to recreate portions of the nephite record attributable to. A recent study coming from stanford university using linguistics has determined that solomon spalding and. What are the arguments against the book of mormon being written by solomon spaulding. The spaulding manuscript in the oberlin college library. In these episodes, we continue our deep dive into explaining the authorship of the book of mormon including these topics. An ongoing study of shared language in spaldings manuscript pages and the book of mormon demonstrates that certain sections of the book of mormon overlap the known spalding writings to a greater degree than do other sections of that book. Ethan smith, hyrum smith, oliver cowdery, solomon spaulding. The myth of the manuscript found, by elder george reynolds. Solomon spaulding and the book of mormon publications matthew b. The problem with the book of mormon, one newspaper editor wrote in 1839, was to account for a work being evidently the production of a cultivated mind, yet found in the hands of an exceedingly ignorant illiterate person. Evidence for solomon spaulding authorship of the book of mormon.
I have recently examined the book of mormon, and find in it the writings of solomon spaulding, from beginning to end, but mixed up with scripture and other religious matter, which i did not meet with in the manuscript found. However, another theory is that the book of mormon was taken from an unpublished 1812 novel written by a retired minister, solomon spalding or spaulding, who died in 1816 in ohio. Im not a mormon and i believe the bom sprang from the mind of joseph smith, but i have no sympathy for proponents of the spalding rigdon theory because it is such a weak, poorlybuttressed alternative explanation. The dartmouth university connections to the book of mormon. Jul 18, 2009 see his manuscript of solomon spaulding and the book of mormon in magazine of western history 4 mayoctober 1886, pp. By relying on the appendices and end notes, they leave the story uncluttered by all of the details. Believers in the book of mormon felt vindicated by this discovery, and they published spauldings work to show the world it was not the source for the book of mormon. Second, the author of the book of mormon wrote this mss. The spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship is the theory that the book of mormon was plagiarized in part from an unpublished manuscript written by solomon spalding. Uncle dales selection of old mormon newspaper article transcripts primarily covering the 18301860 period in latter day saint history the spalding studies web site. The solomon spalding theory chapter 9 of joseph smiths. Debunking the spaulding manuscript theory mormon heretic. Toward a history of the book in early mormon culture david j.
When rice, fairchild, and several others compared the spaulding manuscript with the book of mormon they could detect no resemblance between the two, in general or detail. Solomon spalding manuscript found rough draft for the. We build enduring faith in jesus christ by making the book of mormon accessible, comprehensible, and defensible to the entire world. Aug 04, 2008 joseph smith jr could not have written the b of m nor could he have used spaulding as the basis for it. The book of mormon certainly has difficulty demonstrating that it is ancient history, so does most of the old testament, the conflicting narratives of the gospels, the bhagavad gita, the upanishads and a number of sacred texts. One of the earliest theories was that the book of mormon was based on a manuscript by solomon spaulding also spelled spalding, a fictional story about early inhabitants of america. Solomon spaulding and the book of mormon robert patterson home. Solomon spaulding, the b of mormon joseph smith was. Solomon spalding 17611816 was a lapsed calvinist evangelist, a failed new york businessman, and hopeful author of a prehistoric american epic story giving an account of the vanished mound builders of the ohio valley. I searched to see if this had been discussed and had not found anything, which could be my poor computer search skills. Contains statements of various neighbors of the smiths detailing their magic and money digging involvement. Full text of the manuscript story of reverend solomon. As it turns out, olivers grandfather william cowdery, sr.
Solomon spaulding s manuscript for many years i had heard that some people claimed that the book of mormon was not an original work, but was based on a story written by solomon spaulding about 20 years before the publication of the book of mormon. Smith and orson hyde, missionaries for the church of jesus christ, were in conneaut, ohio, where spaulding began writing his manuscript. The essay discusses the manuscript found document composed by author solomon spaulding and its possible influence on the creation of the book of mormon, along with its depiction of native american life. Cowdrey is an ex mormon whose interest in the origins of the book of mormon derives from his familys tradition that they are relatives of the oliver cowdery who figures so prominently in the spalding enigma. There is a theory that sidney rigdon helped joseph smith create the book of mormon based on a manuscript written by a man named solomon spaulding. Nm page 144, now to his bitter chagrin he found that the long chase had been vain. The complete original religious studies center specialized monograph series, v. He studied at dartmouth college in new hampshire and was ordained a minister. Manuscript found by solomon spalding the controversy between manuscript found and the book of mormon goes all the back to e.
Prior to 2008, no published authorship study results linked sidney rigdon to writing of the book of mormon. Book of mormonauthorship theoriesspalding manuscript. As for the book of mormon, history shows that an innkeeper named solomon spaulding, who was a good storyteller, had been convinced by friends to write down some of his stories in 1815 in order to make money during the recession brought about by the war of 1812. The solomon spaulding manuscript theory of book of mormon authorship. Brandons reward for solving the puzzle is to be a rare copy of the original edition of the book of mormon. Revisiting the seven lineages of the book of mormon and the. Solomon spaulding and the book of mormon fairmormon. Lds church members are taught that the book of mormon bom is scripture, as well as a true record of the inhabitants of the americas from about 2200 bc to 420 ad. For rarely does one find an alternative theory advanced to expose the true origins of a. First book published to challenge the claims of the book of mormon and mormonism. This makes it a must read book for every thinking person on the planet. There is a small group who hold to the theory that the production of the book of mormon was a conspiracy involving sidney rigdon, joseph smith, oliver cowdery and others. Introduction, near the west bank of the coneaught river there are the remains of an ancient fort. The book and the man, joseph smith, kindled a religion that today numbers over nine million members.
Bryce concludes the interview with his personal take on the veracity of the theory. Evidence for solomon spaulding authorship of the book of. Back to mormon quotes index solomon spaulding was born in ashford, conn. I know this has been refuted before, but can you help me understand this issue and get to the. As joseph smith, the founder of the rapidly growing church of jesus christ of latterday saints mormon.
The book repudiated the rigdon spaulding theory, revived the alexander campbell thesis that joseph smith alone was the author of the book, and postulated that view of the hebrews following riley, 1903 provided the basic source material for the book of mormon. Solomon spalding february 20, 1761 october 20, 1816 was the author of two related texts. Historian richard bushman summarizes its life as follows. Solomon spalding february 20, 1761 october 20, 1816 was the author at least two related texts. There are similarities in the explanation for the origins of both manuscript found and the book of mormon. Who was solomon spalding and what connection did his manuscript have with joseph smith. Search for library items search for lists search for contacts search for a library. Spaldingrigdon theory proves the book of mormon is false. Who really wrote the book of mormon solomon spalding.
The curious case of solomon spaulding mormon matters. Pattersons printshop agreed to publish them if he would write a forward. The spalding rigdon theory was first given wide publicity in 1834 with the publication of the book mormonism unvailed. This timeline is a summary of all events that indicate that this theory may be true based on my notes collected over a sixyear period. The theory of the origin of the book of mormon in the traditional manuscript of solomon spaulding will probably have to be relinquished. Since the book of mormon was first published, many have been unwilling to accept joseph smiths account of how it was produced. The theory first appeared in print in the book mormonism unvailed sic, published in 1834 by e. Contents letters vi articles presidential address the web of print. The good news is that this is a very readable book. Solomon spaulding penned a manuscript that joseph smith plagiarized. Readers edition where did the book of mormon come from. Who was solomon spalding and did he have a connection with. Rice, of honolulu, hawaiian islands, formerly an antislavery editor in ohio, and. For almost 200 years now, critics have been scrambling to prove that the book of mormon is nothing but a work of fiction.
Revisiting the seven lineages of the book of mormon and the seven tribes of mesoamerica diane e. Investigating the mysterious origin of the book of mormon wayne l cowdrey, arthur vanick, howard a davis on. In it, the author followed up on indications previously published in ohiobased newspapers that a man named solomon spalding was the real and unwitting originator of the book of mormon this is in contrast to some lds apologists who claim that the author simply. Book of mormon, work accepted as holy scripture, in addition to the bible, in the church of jesus christ of latterday saints and other mormon churches. Smith created the book of mormon through automatic writing. Smiths intellect was sufficient for him to dictate the words in. The solomon spalding manuscript 1812 by solomon spalding this unpublished manuscript was a work of fiction created by a retired minister, solomon spalding who died in 1816 before being able to publish his work. Spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship wikipedia. In 1833, spalding s brother john and seven other residents of conneaut signed affidavits stating that spalding had written a manuscript, portions of which were identical to the book of mormon. The spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship is the theory that the book of mormon was plagiarized in part from an unpublished manuscript. Spauldings novel provides an engaging view into one mans fanciful reconstruction of native american life. This list is in no way meant to prove or disprove the spaldingrigdon theory, nor should it be considered exhaustive by any stretch of the imagination.
In that year, fawn brodie published no man knows my history. While there, they preached from the book of mormon. Spauldings widow, matilda davison, gave the manuscript to hurlburt. Naturalistic explanations of the origin of the book of. The authors present a compelling narrative of the characters and events involved in the creation of book of mormon. For years now ive heard people offhandedly dismiss the book of mormon as a known plagiarism of the solomon spaulding manuscript. Solomon spaulding, the b of mormon joseph smith was functionally illiterate posted by jlfuller on august 4, 2008 joseph smith jr could not have written the b of m nor could he have used spaulding as the basis for it. Items in the bmc archive are made publicly available for noncommercial, private use. Who realy wrote the book of mormon solomon spalding.
Davis, and arthur vinick, is a stunning indictment of the founders of the lds, and thoroughly destroys the entire foundation of the mormon faith itself. Anthony shows up and attempts to steal the valuable book, brandon must use his newfound knowledge of the book of mormon to confront real dangers. Book of mormon by william a, white press staff writer. This library possesses a manuscript which apparently is in the handwriting of solomon spaulding, since it seems to agree with fragments of account books which i have seen, and. That was the first time that it was suggested that the book of mormon had in part at least, some inspiration that originated. Solomon spalding manuscript found rough draft for the book of mormon. Many of the passages in the mormon book are verbatim from spaulding, and others in part. There is a small group who hold to the theory that the production of the book of mormon was a conspiracy involving sidney rigdon, joseph smith, oliver cowdery.
Apr 26, 2009 evidence that the spaulding manuscript is not the source of the book of mormon. The socalled spaulding story has been for many years past the last refuge of those who have undertaken to prove that the book of mormon is not what it. What are the arguments against the book of mormon being. Wirth the number seven had several connotations to the precolumbian communities of mesoamerica. The spalding studies site solomon spalding home page. If the map was shared with the goal of making people think that the spaulding manuscript and the view of the hebrews have a legitimate claim at influencing the writing of the book of mormon, i think its probably missed its mark. Inclusion within the bmc archive does not imply endorsement.
Despite the attempts to suppress it, the book, who really wrote the book of mormon. Brodies interpretations have been followed by several other writers. Is the book of mormon ancient history or a work of. Solomon spalding and revisionist history mormonthink. One of the earliest theories was that the book of mormon was based on a manuscript by solomon spaulding also spelled spalding, a fictional story about. Was the book of mormon given to joseph smith by an angel or created from a work of fiction. Spaulding manuscript mormonism, the mormon church, beliefs. This theory claimed that sidney rigdon wrote the religious parts of the book of mormon while the historical parts were plagiarized from an unpublished manuscript written in 1812 by solomon spaulding rigdon having secretly acquired the spaulding document from a pittsburgh printer named jonathan h.
I have heard that joseph smith plagiarized the writings of solomon spaulding to produce the book of mormon. Spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship. How philosopher emanuel swedenborg, reverend alexander campbell, professor john smith of dartmouth, solomon spalding, and ethan smith influenced sidney rigdon and joseph smith to plagurize the book of mormon from manusript found, view of the. But it will not take long for readers to see that it bears no resemblance to the book of mormon. Fairchild concluded that the theory of the origin of the book of mormon in the traditional manuscript of solomon spaulding will probably have to be relinquished. When applied to the book of mormon, wordprinting reveals that the word patterns of the book of mormon differ significantly from the personal writings of joseph smith, solomon spaulding, sidney rigdon, and oliver cowdery, who served as joseph smiths scribe. Howe suggested, basing himself on witnesses collected by doctor hurlbut, that the book of mormon was a revised form of a fictional work written by solomon spalding. In it, the author followed up on indications previously published in ohiobased newspapers that a man named solomon spalding was the real and unwitting originator of the book of mormon this is in contrast to. View of the hebrews1823 book of mormon 1829 very very.
The spaulding fable by common consent, a mormon blog. For a long time this seemed the accepted theory of all nonmormons. In the early 1830s he was identified by some witnesses and writers as the original author of part of the book of mormon. It was not long, however, before a number of people realised that the view of the hebrews and the book of mormon had some rather startling similarities. It was first published in 1830 in palmyra, new york, and was thereafter widely reprinted and translated.
In the late 1960s, a young latterday saint discovered that an ancient form of middle eastern poetry was found throughout the book of mormon, suggestive of its ancient semitic origins. His preparation, thorough research, and absolute brilliance are on display as bryce gives us the context surrounding the solomon spaulding manuscript theory of the book of mormoneven including some of the apologetic arguments against the theory. Ive finally gotten around to researching this oftcited alternative theory about the true origins of the book of mormon, and i was both perplexed and amused by what i found. Was the famous book of mormon written under another title by rev. However, almost none of these people have actually read manuscript story for themselves. Looking at the spaulding manuscript mormon heretic. Had hurlbut invented the theory and falsely extracted testimony from his witnesses, he would not have made strenuous efforts to recover spauldings manuscript. Hurlbut did not invent the spaulding theory, but was drawn to spauldings former residence in conneaut, ohio, to investigate claims that some residents were making about the book of mormon. Book of mormon difficulties, contradictions and explanations. Full text of the manuscript story of reverend solomon spalding.
As one hardy boys mystery is similar to another, so spaulding s the manuscript found is similar to the book of mormon. In 1834, four years after its first appearance, an effort was made to show that the book of mormon was a plagiarism from an unpublished novel of solomon spaulding. The spalding enigma did an angel of god in the late 1820s really give 18yearold con artist joseph smith mormon bible, as he claimed. The most interesting literary controversy of the time, and the only one which has important practical bearing, is raging around the book of mormon, sometimes but incorrectly called the mormon bible.
Collaborators assisted smith in writing the book of mormon. Believing mormons often state that solomon spaldings manuscript story if you are unfamiliar with the spaldingrigdon theory, click here for a brief background has absolutely nothing in common with the book of mormon. Howes 1834 book mormonism unvailed, in which the theory was presented that the book of mormon was plagiarized. Spaulding manuscript the encyclopedia of mormonism.
Mental illness expanded smiths abilities to write the book of mormon. Bushman on spaulding by common consent, a mormon blog. One of the earliest theories of book of mormon authorship was that joseph plagiarized the unpublished manuscript of a novel written by the reverend solomon spalding. That manuscript is doubtless now in the possession of mr. Items do not represent the official views of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints or of book of mormon central.
1055 1396 1190 969 62 1257 1460 1397 1578 1007 1447 364 297 577 804 1177 941 442 1008 1345 1082 1014 1471 228 215 260 1119 126 967 1490 1293 1254 824 1319 319 532 82 1342 941